Blog

When Should a Customs Broker Bring in Legal Counsel?

November 5, 2026
Blog Main Image
Share

Most of your clients' IEEPA refunds run through you. You find the entries, you file the Consolidated Automated Processing and Execution (CAPE) declaration, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) reliquidates, and the money comes back.

But some files don't stay in that lane. The refund turns on a lawsuit, a deadline, or a decision about a class action, and that's not customs business anymore. Holding onto those files too long can cost the client money they're owed.

So when should a customs broker bring in legal counsel? Here are the four signals we see most often, and how the handoff should work.

‍

Signal 1: The entries already finalized

This is the clearest one.

CAPE normally accepts entries that liquidated within about 80 days. Once an entry has been liquidated for more than 90 days, it's what the Court of International Trade (CIT), the federal court that hears customs disputes, calls finally liquidated. CBP's own window to reopen it has closed.

CBP opened Phase 3 of CAPE on October 6, 2026 for those entries. But Phase 3 only covers entries where the CIT has ordered reliquidation, which means importers that filed their own lawsuit. It's also limited to plaintiffs that gave CBP a valid importer of record number by July 30, 2026; CBP says instructions for later plaintiffs are coming, without a date.

So for finalized entries, the sequence is lawsuit, court order, then a Phase 3 CAPE declaration. You may still file that last step. The lawsuit that gets the client there is counsel's work.

Have a client with entries that liquidated months ago? Call us at (602) 610-6127 and we'll tell you fast whether litigation is in play.

‍

Signal 2: The client asks whether to sue or wait for the class action

Expect this question more often now.

On October 8, 2026, the CIT certified a class in Freestyle World, Inc. v. U.S. Customs and Border Protection. It covers importers of record that paid IEEPA duties between February 1, 2025 and February 19, 2026, excluding companies that filed their own lawsuits.

That sounds like the waiting option just got safer. Maybe. But certification isn't a refund order, the court hasn't ordered reliquidation for the class, and the government may still try to appeal the certification.

Filing an individual case takes a company out of the class. Staying in means waiting on a process with no refund date. Weighing those is a legal judgment about the client's specific entries and risk, and it's the kind of question a broker shouldn't be left answering alone.

‍

Signal 3: There is a deadline the client can't see

Litigation clocks don't show up in Automated Commercial Environment (ACE).

Individual CIT cases like these have a two-year statute of limitations under 28 U.S.C. § 2636(i). Exactly when the clock starts on a given entry isn't fully settled, but the earliest deadlines are expected in early 2027. And the class certification order doesn't say whether the class action pauses that clock for class members.

Early 2027 sounds far off. It isn't, once you count the time to pull the full entry history, confirm IEEPA duties entry by entry, and get a complaint filed correctly.

‍

Protests are part of the same question

Protests have been an unreliable path for IEEPA duties. But a protest on file doesn't block Phase 3, and what happens to it after a court order matters.

The practice that's emerged: once the client has a reliquidation order and confirms Phase 3 eligibility, the IEEPA protest can be withdrawn. Protests that also cover other issues, like classification or valuation, shouldn't be withdrawn unless the client is willing to give up those claims. That's a call to make with counsel before anyone clicks withdraw.

Not sure whether a client's protests or deadlines are a problem? Send us the entries for a refund review.

‍

Signal 4: The duties at issue aren't plain IEEPA duties

CAPE was built for IEEPA refunds. Other tariffs your clients paid sit on different tracks, and most of those tracks run through the courts.

The Section 122 surcharge is the main example. The CIT ruled against it in May 2026, but only for the plaintiffs in that case, and the Federal Circuit has stayed that ruling while the government appeals. Section 122 duties aren't refunded through CAPE.

Section 301 forced-labor duties are being challenged in the CIT too, and there's no refund path unless the court sets them aside. Section 232 and other Section 301 duties remain in force.

When a client asks "can we get those back too," the honest answer depends on litigation that's still moving. That's a question for trade counsel.

‍

What a clean handoff looks like

Bringing in counsel doesn't mean handing off the client. The best files split cleanly.

You keep what you're licensed and positioned to do: identifying entries, organizing the data, and filing CAPE declarations, including Phase 3 declarations once a court order is in place. We handle the CIT case, the class-or-sue analysis, and the fight over how refunds get paid.

‍

What to send counsel

The handoff goes faster when the file arrives with:

  • The entry list with IEEPA duties paid on each entry
  • Liquidation dates and current status for every entry
  • CAPE declarations already filed and their outcomes
  • Any protests on file, and which issues each one covers
  • The importer of record number and who the importer of record actually is

At Frost Law AZ, our attorneys handle IEEPA recovery from the data review through the CIT case and the refund itself, working alongside the broker, not around them. The client sees one coordinated team.

Seeing one of these four signals on a client file? Tell us what you're working with in the form below, and we'll give you a straight read on whether it's time to bring in counsel.

‍

Sources